A List of Reviews Of Old Comics

Here’s the ranking of best to worst in my Reviews of Old Comics. Why best to worst? Let’s keep this as positive as possible, but some of you just want to hear me rant about bad comics, so you can scroll to the bottom of the list. I should also point out that comics with the same rating are listed alphabetically.

First, let’s have a word about the rankings and the prevalence of higher ranked comics. An absolutely average comic would be ranked as a 5.0, and going in, I start there and things either take it higher or lower. I tend not to spend my time writing reviews about comics that I hate. There’s nothing to be gained from it, so I rarely do it. My exception would be key issues or special requests.

If you want to read a particular review, just click the cover image for that comic. Hopefully, I’ve coded it all correctly.

   Legion of Super-Heroes 1 

10.0 – Legion of Super-Heroes #305
9.8 – New Teen Titans #39
9.5 – Avengers Annual #10
9.5 – Legion of Super-Heroes #1
9.5 – Saga Of The Swamp Thing #34

    

9.5 – Watchmen #1
9.3 – New Teen Titans #38
9.2 – Fantastic Four #258
9.0 – Authority #1
9.0 – Batman: The Killing Joke

    

9.0 – Bram Stoker’s Dracula #3
9.0 – Infinity Gauntlet #1
9.0 – Legion of Super-Heroes #303
9.0 – Legion of Super-Heroes #304
9.0 – Legion of Super-Heroes #311

    

9.0 – Legion of Super-Heroes #312
9.0 – Legion of Super-Heroes #313
9.0 – Legionnaires #7
9.0 – Star Wars #38
8.7 – All-Star Squadron #22

    

8.7 – Tales of the Legion #315
8.7 – What If #11
8.5 – Batman and the Outsiders #32
8.5 – Crisis On Infinite Earths #11
8.5 – Elementals #22

    

8.5 – Excalibur #1
8.5 – Fantastic Four #265
8.5 – Legion of Super-Heroes #310
8.5 – Legion of Super-Heroes #2
8.5 – Morningstar Special #1

    
8.5 – New Mutants #18
8.5 – Super Powers #5
8.5 – Tales of Legion #314
8.5 – Tales of the Teen Titans #50
8.5 – Twilight #1

    

8.5 – Typhoid #1
8.5 – Uncanny X-Men #213
8.5 – Unity #0
8.5 – Zatanna: Everyday Magic
8.0 – All-Star Squadron #29

    

8.0 – Avengers #181 
8.0 – Bill & Ted’s Excellent Comic Book
8.0 – Elementals #8
8.0 – Elementals #2
8.0 – E-Man #2

    

8.0 – Legion of Super-Heroes #307
8.0 – Marvel Graphic Novel #4
8.0 – Power Pack #1
8.0 – Prez #4
8.0 – Red Sonja #1

    

8.0 – Sensational She-Hulk #31
8.0 – Shade The Changing Man #19
8.0 – Star Wars: Heir To The Empire #1
8.0 – Superboy & The Legion Of Super-Heroes #257
8.0 – What If #35

    

7.5 – Adventure Comics #342
7.5 – Batman Adventures #12
7.5 – Cloak & Dagger #1
7.5 – John Byrne’s Next Men #6
7.5 – Justice League of America #190

    

7.5 – Legion of Super-Heroes #309
7.5 – Legion of Super-Heroes Annual #2
7.5 – Minimum Wage #2
7.5 – Namor the Sub-Mariner #8
7.5 – Sensational She-Hulk #5

    

7.5 – Tales To Offend #1
7.3 – Plasm #0
7.0 – Avengers #214
7.0 – Elementals #12
7.0 – Legion of Super-Heroes #306

    

7.0 – Legion of Super-Heroes #308
7.0 – Legion of Super-Heroes #92
7.0 – Marvel Super-Heroes Secret Wars #2
7.0 – Starstream #3
7.0 – Uncanny X-Men #152

    

6.5 – Iron Man #152
6.5 – Power Man & Iron Fist #50
6.5 – Ripley’s Believe It Or Not #71
6.5 – Star Wars #8
6.5 – Zero Hour #0

     

6.0 – Fantastic Four #1
6.0 – Samuree #1
6.0 – Valor #18
5.0 – Dazzler #1
5.0 – Dazzler #34
5.0 – Hansi, The Girl Who Loved The Swastika

    

5.0 – What If #34
4.0 – Deadpool #1
3.5 – Spider-Woman #5
3.0 – DC Comics Presents #87
3.0 – New Mutants #98